about Grace Hodgson Flandrau and Judge Charles Eugene Flandrau

After readings in books by, and about Charles Macomb Flandrau, I became interested in his sister-in-law Grace.   

I did surmise that Charle's early promotion of her work, diminished as her popularity grew and began to out-shine his own.  

Selected Bibliography

 Of Grace Hodgson Flandrau

 Cousin Julia (1917)

Being Respectable (1923)

Entranced (1924)

The Lewis and Clark Expedition (1927)

Then I Saw the Congo (1929)

Indeed This Flesh (1934)

Under the Sun: Tales of Love and Death (1936)

Memoirs of Grace Flandrau (2003)

Grace Flandrau was the sister-in-law and close friend of architect Theodate Pope Riddle, who provided her with a life tenancy in a house on the Hill-Stead estate in Farmington, Connecticut. Flandrau died there on December 27, 1971 at the age of 85. By the time her will was probated in 1973, her estate was valued at $10,000,000

 

The Patriarch was Charles Eugene Flandrau (July 15, 1828 – September 9, 1903) He was an American lawyer who became influential in the Minnesota Territory, and later state, after moving there in 1853 from New York City. He served on the Minnesota Territorial Council, in the Minnesota Constitutional Convention, and on the Minnesota territorial and state supreme courts. He was also an associate justice on the Minnesota Supreme Court.

Judge Flandrau was married twice. His first marriage was on August 10, 1859 to his first cousin, Isabella Dinsmore of Kentucky, the daughter of Martha Macomb and James Dinsmore. The couple had two daughters, Martha Macomb and Sarah Gibson Flandrau, before Isabella died in 1867. Martha married Tilden Russell Selmes; their daughter, Isabella Selmes, became the first female congresswoman from Arizona, known by her married name of Isabella Greenway.

Flandrau married again to Rebecca B. Riddle, a widow and daughter of Judge William McClure and his wife of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. They had two sons. Charles Macomb and William Blair who married Grace Hodgson.

During the Dakota War, Flandrau enlisted in the Union Army and was commissioned as a captain in 1862 to raise a force to defend settlers at New Ulm. Given his success, the governor appointed him to lead the defense of southwest Minnesota, at the rank of colonel.  Flandrau moved to St. Paul, where he had a law partnership with his former Court colleague, Isaac Atwater, before being elected Minneapolis City Attorney in 1867. He died in 1903 and is buried in Oakland Cemetery. 

Her body was moved to St. Paul and buried in Oakland Cemetery, St. Paul, Minn. in the family plot near her husband William Blair Flandrau and brother-in-law. Charles Malcomb Flandrau. Her grave is marked with a single small stone.

The Private Life of Charles Macomb Flandrau

 Charles Macomb Flandrau (1871-1938) ...best known for his 1909 travel book Viva Mexico! He was born in St. Paul, Minnesota, the son of noted lawyer Charles Eugene Flandrau, educated at Harvard but didn't receive a degree.  His experiences there formed the basis of his first book Harvard Episodes (1897). This small book was read by those who felt it's sting, and those who rejoiced at the snob-set getting a come-uppance. Commissioned pieces for the Saturday Evening Post followed as Flandrau became a popular contributor at the turn of the century. Flandrau’s other books did not prove to be as successful.  

Lawrence Peter Haeg has written two books on Flandrau: Little Corners of Great Places: The Private Life of Charles Macomb Flandrau (1981) and In Gatsby's Shadow  Shadow : The Story of Charles Macomb Flandrau (2004). 

I certainly enjoyed this book. As it was night time reading, I did it in small bites and enjoyed savoring it and also the after taste.  My objection is to the title as it has so little to do with F. Scott Fitzgerald 

  

Larry Haeg observes, "Flandrau felt literature was being prostituted, monetized, taken under the tent of the new mass media, and made a cultural circus featuring what he called 'trained performers"

 

Theodore Roosevelt often stayed on the Flandrau house when he was in Saint Paul.  The families were frequent correspondents. Many of the letters are archived in the Theodore Roosevelt Collection at the State University of Dickenson, Dickenson North Dakota

"Flandrau, a model of style and worldly sophistication and destined, almost everyone agreed, for greatness, was among the most talented young writers of his generation. His short stories about Harvard in the 1890s were called “the first realistic description of undergraduate life in American colleges”

Yet Flandrau turned his back on it all. Financially independent, he chose a solitary, epicurean life in St. Paul, Mexico, Majorca, Paris, and Normandy. In later years, he confined his writing to local newspaper pieces and letters to his small circle of family and friends."

"Using excerpts from these newspaper columns and unpublished letters, Larry Haeg has painstakingly recreated the story of this urbane, talented, witty, lazy, enigmatic, supremely private man who never reached the peak of literary success to which his talent might have taken him."(from publisher, Iowa University Press) 

 I have now also read Viva Mexico. He shares observations of life on his brother's coffee plantation. He carefully reports about growing coffee, the scenery, the workers, and the visitors. Interesting that in 1908 there wasn't a genre for memoirs which is where I will shelve it. 

President Theodore Roosevelt's Letter 

upon receiving Viva Mexico as a gift from

the Theodore Roosevelt collection at The

State University of Dickenson in Dickenson,

North Dakota                      

I was interested in finding out more about Larry Haeg and borrowed his new (2013) book, Harriman vs. Hill from the library.   Too much "Wall Street" and banking talk for me but I am enjoying the personal portraits.  Informative descriptions of the actual railroad building and the agricultural history continue to be good reasons to stick with it. There is a big demand for this book in our library system.  

 

photos from the article "In Search of the Real Grace Flandrau" by Georgia Ray

Minnesota History, Summer 1999

Now Reading: Loquacities by Charles Macomb Flandrau

Contents; The Bustle, an episode of the eighties -- Memory and Mrs. Grinder -- Yellowed with Age --Peace, Perfect Peace -- Arrival -- The Colonel's Hat -- Hotel de la Grille -- Melodeons and Hoop Skirts -- Of Earthquakes -- Hello! Hello! -- "The Old Things" -- Rag bag -- The Guignol, Revisited -- The Colt -- Jarana at breakfast.